This look was done using the "Fashion Eyes" tutorial in the Too Faced Natural Eye kit. It's more metallic than I prefer but I wanted to actually utilize the cards that came with the kit, so I just decided to go with it and stick to the true look. I did like it; I just normally would have gone for a matte highlight since there's so much shine going on with the lid colors. Next time :)
If you don't have the Natural Eyes Kit, I definitely recommend it! It's super versatile. However, for this look all you really need is a warm gold, dark reddish brown, and a skintoned metallic highlight color.